The Hudson Budget Committee heard an explanation for higher-than-expected legal expenses during its Nov. 4 meeting, with town officials pointing to an ongoing property tax lawsuit involving Eversource as one of the major factors affecting next year’s budget.
Although efforts have been made to keep the upcoming budget “lean,” officials said some legal expenses were unavoidable.
“Right now, we have a significant court case with Eversource, primarily on the transmission value of a property,” said Town Accountant Jim Lockwood, referring to the value defense portion of a slightly higher legal budget line.
Lockwood explained that property tax assessment cases are often handled jointly with other Southern New Hampshire communities to help reduce legal costs. However, he said the Eversource case could be more expensive.
“This one does not promise to be as cheap as some of them; we expect to go to trail sometime later in 2027, and we don’t expect that Eversource is going to be terribly reasonable in settlement discussion,” he said.
According to the lawsuit, Eversource is challenging property tax assessment methodologies used by Hudson and several other Southern New Hampshire communities.
“It’s a significant value for us, and we’re going to have to pay a lot more in legal fees to manage this Eversource case,” Lockwood said. “That’s not the only property owner in town that is significant that could be bringing us to court over the property taxes.”
Lockwood noted that challenges to property tax assessments are not uncommon, particularly given Hudson’s relatively large commercial and industrial tax base.
He pointed to a recent walk-through of Target’s logistics center, which included the company’s tax attorney. However, Lockwood said the town was not anticipating an immediate tax appeal from Target, explaining that such involvement was sometimes considered part of the “due diligence” conducted by large commercial property owners.
“What’s the difference in valuation between where Eversource thinks they should be at and where we think they should be at?” asked Budget Committee member Shawn Jasper. “That case seems to account for roughly $50,000 of the $98,000 legal line.”
Town officials did not immediately have the valuation figures available but said they would provide the information to the Budget Committee in the coming weeks.
Lockwood indicated that the difference in the valuations was “significant,” adding that smaller assessment disputes rarely make it to court because of the legal expenses involved.
Lockwood also explained why utility companies may have an incentive to challenge property tax assessments.
“We pay their taxes you know, it’s in our kilowatt rates. But when Eversource goes to set rates with the state, the regulators say ‘Wow, you have a really large expense here. What are you doing to reduce this large expense?’ There’s almost an incentive there where utility companies feel the need to be able to say they’re reducing costs, including property taxes,” Lockwood explained.
Town Administrator Roy Sorenson said the higher legal budget line also reflected a decision to consolidate several expenses that had previously been spread across different budget categories.
“We were paying legal fees out of both this budget and assessing, so we just decided to put it all into legal. If you want to go into the numbers and look at assessing, you’ll see a negative,” Sorenson explained. “It deals with value defense for assessing related costs. Other issues like general counsel and labor counsel and things of that nature are other lines.”
Sorenson also noted that labor counsel expenses were slightly higher than usual because of ongoing collective bargaining negotiations.
